home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1098>
- <title>
- Aug. 22, 1994: Justice:The Citadel Still Holds
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Aug. 22, 1994 Stee-rike!
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- JUSTICE, Page 61
- The Citadel Still Holds
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> A last-minute federal appeals-court decision keeps Shannon Faulkner
- from becoming a cadet
- </p>
- <p>By David Van Biema--Reported by Bonnie I. Rochman/Charleston
- </p>
- <p> Quiet satisfaction suffuses Big John's bar in Charleston, South
- Carolina, an establishment that caters to the Citadel, the town's
- revered military school. The Icehouse draft beer is flowing,
- and all's well with the world; or, more precisely, everything's
- in its place. The Confederate flag and the flag of the South
- Carolina secession are tacked next to Old Glory near the ceiling;
- the IMPEACH CLINTON sticker beneath the flags seems practically
- to glow; the cadets and their sweethearts are crowding the red
- vinyl-covered benches; and Shannon Faulkner's hair--the proximate
- cause for the celebratory mood--is still on her head.
- </p>
- <p> Faulkner, 19, will not be getting a crew cut on Monday. Nor
- will she be forced to walk in gutters instead of on sidewalks.
- She will not be assuming the distorted "brace" position to accept
- any abuse an upperclassman cares to dish out. Or doing push-ups
- until she vomits. She will not be submitting to--or struggling
- against--any of the everyday humiliations imposed during the
- freshman year at the Citadel, the all-male military college
- that is Charleston's pride, because, as of Friday, a federal
- appeals court won't let her.
- </p>
- <p> There is no law on the books preventing people from injecting
- themselves into uncomfortable situations. And it is Faulkner's
- hope, now somewhat dented, that there are laws preventing them
- from being excluded. The Citadel is, without doubt, one of Southern
- education's more idiosyncratic institutions. Founded in 1842
- (it boasts that its cadets fired the first shots of the Civil
- War: at a Union ship), the college is a proud dinosaur of the
- Old South, notable today for two things. One is its alumni network,
- which includes at least one South Carolina Senator, one former
- Governor and countless other sons of Dixie whose extraordinary
- mutual loyalty gives them enormous local clout. The other is
- its abysmal treatment of freshmen, or "knobs," so named because
- their shaved heads resemble doorknobs. Some claim the first
- flows from the second, as adversity forges lasting friendships.
- Others say it's not worth it: the school has withstood claims
- of hazing, particularly an incident involving a black cadet.
- </p>
- <p> It was Faulkner's choice to take the bad with the good. She
- applied--and was accepted--last year. Then the Citadel,
- learning she was female, reneged. Faulkner sued for discrimination--the school is state funded--and last month, Federal District
- Judge C. Weston Houck ruled in her favor, saying she could attend
- the school as a full-fledged cadet beginning with the start
- of the new school year--this Monday.
- </p>
- <p> Citadel stalwarts were deeply wounded. Said retired Lieut. Colonel
- T. Nugent Courvoisie, 77, immortalized as the Citadel's harsh
- taskmaster, the "Bear," in Pat Conroy's best seller The Lords
- of Discipline, last Wednesday: "That girl says she wants to
- come in and be one of the boys. But the minute she comes in,
- the atmosphere changes. She ruins the whole concept of getting
- everyone together and working on the same team." In fact, there
- may be some truth to claims by other traditionalists that once
- Faulkner is in, rather than playing by the Citadel's rules,
- she (or her legal team) hopes to change the place. After their
- initial victory, her lawyers asked Houck to excuse her from
- the traditional knob crew cut, on the shaky grounds that it
- would stigmatize her as a woman. More sensibly, given recent
- threats on Faulkner's life and fear of cadet harassment, attorney
- Sara Mandelbaum promised, "We'll be monitoring Shannon's progress
- closely--and we'll hold the administration accountable."
- </p>
- <p> Last Wednesday, Houck ruled again, this time in favor of the
- haircut. Previously, he had accepted the Citadel's demand that
- Faulkner be housed by herself in a renovated area of the school's
- infirmary. Faulkner's enrollment, however, seemed inevitable,
- and as she prepared gamely for her desired ordeal, Citadel graduates
- like Buck Limehouse (class of '60), now chairman of the South
- Carolina department of transportation commission, tried to put
- their disappointment in a historical context: "It's sort of
- like the Southern cause," he said. "Even if you know you're
- going to lose the war, if you believe in the principles you're
- fighting for, you fight anyway."
- </p>
- <p> Then at the last moment, the South rose again. On Friday an
- appeals court granted the Citadel a stay pending a hearing of
- arguments, which will probably take place in December. That
- will effectively postpone Faulkner's cadet debut for at least
- a year. For now she intends to continue as a day student. She
- said, "I'd say I'm being selfish and doing this just for me.
- But I do, in a way, think it's for women who might follow me."
- </p>
- <p> At the Citadel they announced the news over the school's intercom
- system. Brian Wamsley, a 1992 graduate working at the school's
- computer center, reported that "it was just like winning the
- World Series. People were yelling and screaming and slapping
- high fives. It was chaos." For the moment no one seemed worried
- about Faulkner's intent to appeal the case as high as necessary.
- "It's good to know there are still some conservative people
- in this nation," said Wamsley. "We'll definitely be toasting
- the courts tonight."
- </p>
- <p> Bear Courvoisie may be a little old for the bar scene, but he
- can be reached at home. "It's like the second Fourth of July
- around here," he allows. And, to a friend calling with congratulations:
- "Thank you. Thank God. Thank everybody else." The world that
- made him what he is is safe for another day.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-